Tomkins PLC Win in the European Court of Justice
January 16, 2013
On January 16, 2013, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) released information confirming its rejection of the appeal of the European Commission (EC) to the judgment of the General Court, which reduced a fine imposed on Tomkins PLC based on the infringement of Article 101 (price-fixing) by its former subsidiary Pegler. The underlying issue in the case was the liability of the parent company, Tomkins, for the alleged violations of its former subsidiary, Pegler. Both Pegler and Tomkins appealed the judgment of the EC. The General Court reduced the fine on Pegler based on evidence available only to Pegler about the duration of the conduct, and reduced the fine as well on Tomkins for the same reasons.
The ECJ ruled for the first time that a parent company, in its capacity simply as a passive shareholder, cannot be held liable independently of the subsidiary and cannot be held liable to a greater extent than its subsidiary. Tomkins successfully preserved a reduced fine and the court awarded Tomkins costs, including attorneys’ fees. The decision that a shareholder company cannot be punished more than the subsidiary has potentially broad implications for competition cases before the European Court.
Axinn has served as chief counsel to Tomkins by lead partner John DEQ. Briggs. The firm was unable to appear for Tomkins before the ECJ, but advised Tomkins throughout the appellate process.
To subscribe to our publications, click here.
Featured Insights
Featured Insights
GCR Live: Law Leaders Europe 2025
Speaking Engagement
Antitrust
Navigating Compliance: How the 2025 Hart-Scott-Rodino Updates Are Impacting Businesses
Webinar
Antitrust
AHLA Annual Meeting 2025
Speaking Engagement
Antitrust
SABA North America Annual Conference 2025
Speaking Engagement
Antitrust
Volunteer Lawyers for the Arts – Champions of the Arts Awards and Gala 2025
Sponsorship
Antitrust
Washington Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights and Urban Affairs – 2025 Wiley A. Branton Awards Luncheon
Sponsorship
Antitrust
What's Happening in Germany and Portugal? Catching Up With International Enforcers at the 2025 Spring Meeting
Podcast
Antitrust
Partner Jason Murata Appointed to the Board of Directors of the National LGBTQ+ Bar Association
Workplace Culture & Opportunity
Managing Partner Jeny Maier Named to Global Competition Review's Women in Antitrust
Awards & Recognitions
Antitrust
Axinn Partners Named to WIPR's Leaders 2025 Directory
Awards & Recognitions
Intellectual Property